
Gonna indulge in some stream-of-consciousness ranting here.
I yield to no one in my unabashed enthusiasm for all things
Battlestar Galactica. It hits the same part of my brain where
Buffy the Vampire Slayer,
Angel and
Firefly (and films such as
The Lord of the Rings) still flourish.
But, it's the accumulated lapses in logic and simple continuity in those works that tear me, kicking and screaming, out of my freely given suspension-of-disbelief. It's only in a multi-episode series or a multi-hour "epic" film where lapses of that sort really claw at me -- the extended time-frame allows for the accumulation of errata and illogic which invariably push me past the tipping point. Why don't the directors/producers/writers see it too? And, why doesn't it seem to bother people as brilliant as Joss Whedon and Ron Moore and Peter Jackson? Is it just because they are who they are and Nobody's The Boss of Them? (Don't even get me started on that fat bastard, George Lucas ...)
Frankly, it's the cognitive dissonance of a sharply written, intriguingly plotted, excellently cast and acted yet studiedly "religion-free" series like
Buffy that can make frequent use of a crucifix and holy water as plot devices while having nothing good whatsoever to say about organized religion of any kind that REALLY irks me. Or, how about the glaring illogic of a bleak, permanently overcast, post-apocalyptic "Earth" left entirely uninhabitable by a nuclear holocaust 2000 years in the past (where uncorroded pocket watches and metal jacks can be pulled out of the sand on a
saltwater beach), yet under seemingly identical circumstances on the planet Caprica, hundreds if not thousands of cylons putter about the depopulated cities sipping lattes within days of dropping "The Big One," as if they hadn't just scoured the surface of 99% of all human and animal life (OK, maybe just 95%). And, Peter Jackson, I've got my eye on you too! “Nobody tosses a dwarf”?!?! At what point did you put down Tolkien's masterwork and pick up some ginned-up version of “
Harry Potter's Excellent Adventures” for tips on cohesive, consistent,
authentic character dialogue?
There's obviously
much more to it than just those few examples (obvious to me, and adverb abusers everywhere, anyway). I'll delve into it further at some later date. Just the tip o' the iceberg.